header image

Student Response Post #2: Regarding “The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe,” which did you prefer…the novel or the movie (and WHY)??

Posted by: stark | March 31, 2008 |

land_narnia.jpg

Please post your response hereĀ using AT LEAST 3 sentences.

under: Students

Responses - Create a free edublog to get your own comment avatar (and more!)

I prefer the novel because it tells a lot of information that it didn’t tell in the movie.

I THINK I WOULD PICK THE NOVEL BECASE IT DESCRIBES A LOT OF STUFF THAT HAPPEN. IN PLUS THE NOVEL WAS MUCH MORE BETTER BECAUSE IT GAVE A LOT OF DETAILS IN THE BOOK. BUT I STILL THINK THE MOVIE WAS GOOD!!!!

I think I like the movie better. Because instead of reading the great adventure, you could see it. And it’s like you are in the movie. There is more action in the movie.

I’d prefer the movie because it gives you more feel about what’s happening and you can rather see what is going on then read the pages with no pictures.It also has more action in it to be intense and fun.

Out of the book and the movie of the lion the Witch and the Wardrobe I like the movie the best. I like it the best because it tells what happend in the beginning. I also like it better because I think it is easier to under stand what is going on better if I can see it.

The movie because I thought it was cooler than the book including the part where they met Aslan.

I think the book is better. I think the book is very much better because I imagined it in my head while I was reading. I think that the book also has more voilence. The book is better.

My favorite one is the movie because its really good how the creatures are realistic. I didnt get to see the ending because I had to go to band. I really like the movie.

I like the movie because they show you more pictures than in the movie. I can understand better with the movie. There is more personality in the movie.

I like the movie better than the novel. I like the movie better because it has a l lot of action. Narnia is very wonderful in the movie.

I would perfer the movie because you can see the pictures and feel like your inside the movie.

I like the movie better than the book. I like it better because Its easier for me to comprehend when I see it. I also like it because it explains why there at the professor’s house. It has more drama.

I like the book better.You can imagine the pictures how you want.The sounds too.

I would rather prefer the movie because I like to watch TV.The movie is pretty good at least I liked it. I liked how they were on the advantages.

The movie because I thought it was cooler than the book including the part where they met Aslan.

I like the movi . It got more action . It very good

I have to say the movie was way cooler especially the big battle scene but the books battle scene was wierd.

I like the movie alot better because you don’t have to imagine the pictures in your head. Trust me its alot esear than it sounds. thats why I like the movie better.

I like the movie better than the book. I like it better because it was shorter than the book. I also liked the movie because you get to see the battle.

i liked the movie better than the book. i liked it because you could actually see the stuff that was happaning. that is why i like the movie better. @(*_*)@ monkey face!!!!!

i like the movie better. i like it better because there was more action and adventure in the movie than the book it was also cooler. That is why i like the movie better. @(*_*)@

I like the movie better than the book because you can understand it better. Also i like the movie better because it expains the battle better. That is why i like it better.

I liked the movie because it had more action in it.
Also the book was good to but I really liked the movie, when you are reading a book and you have to stop because you are. Only reading one chapter that stinks i always wanted to. Keep going on and on but we had to stop.

I like the movie because it as more details. and i undertand it more than the book. i also like the movie better then the book because the movie is one of my favorite movies! :)

I liked the movie more.I liked it because of the same reasons as Oscar. Aslan and the Witch look cooler.

The movie because it includes the bobms. Also because it shows what happens more clearer.Also cause I like the movie

I think that after reading the book and watching the movie, I really prefer the movie better. I think that the movie gave a better idea of what was happening. Also in the beginning of the movie, I could tell why Lucy, Peter, Susan, and Edmund were the at the professor’s mansion. I also liked how the movie gave you more of a feeling of bravery, couragousness, and emotion.

After reading the novel, The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe, and watched the movie, I prefered the movie even though I normally enjoy the books more. The movie had more drama and gave a better idea of the differant scenes throughout the story. For example, in the movie, the reason for Susan, Lucy, Edmond, and Peter being were forced from there home and in turn living with the proffessor was better explained. I also really liked the battle scenes more in the movie because of the music that gives you a feeling of bravery and strong emotion. Beyond all of that, in the book, I became a bit confused about the time that Aslan sacrificed himself for Edmond even after reading it three seperste times. In the movie I was able to see what the words were supposed to mean even if we didn’t understand it while reading. I enjoyed the movie more then the book for those reasons and I hope that you agree with me.

I like the moive better. The frist reson is the lion acted like his age. the second is Edman did not have a sicksh face. The last is I like to see it instead of hear.

I would say that I like the book. I like it because it has more details and a lot more action in it. Also it’s longer and its so great. Another thing is that it shows pictures that people can understand. It explains what they do and how they do it. I like the movie but not as much as the book. When they first meet the person at the door it told me that Edmund was laughing but trying to cover his laughter. I totally like the book. I also like its cover. It details a lot of things that are not detailed in movies like the maple trees and the flowers that grew. It helped me imagine the witch in real life of how she looked like and how tall was she. The book is better.

I perfer the book more than the move. I like book more because the book is more discriptive. The move was not good because it scipt a lot.

I like the moive better. The moive showed you all the action. It was so sad when Aslan died. When Edman got stabed it was so gross.

I prefer the movie because I like how the diricter made the whole movie. It still skips a lot of stuff but i also like when Aslen kills the witch in the movie. I also like how how they made a relly cool lion.

I liked the moive a lot better! I like the moive better because it had a really cool battle seen! It also was a lot cooler than the book because they make you feel like your there.
There are some ggod parts about the book though, here is a good example there are alot more details in the book, and it was longer.
That concludes my point.

I like the movie The Lion the Wicth and the Wardrobe better. The reason why is because it’s more exiting. It just seems more actiony than the book does. The book might seem interesting but the movie is probaly better the book.

@(*_*)@

The movie beacause I think it shows more stuff than the book. It shows what it really looks like. I like the movie beeter than the book.

I prefer the movie better. It has a lot mora action in it. It also look so real. The book wasn’t as good as I thought

I like the movie better because it has more scene in it than the book. I also like the movie better because I’m not a reader lover. One other reason why I liked the movie better was because I could see it and not have to read words and picture it out.

I like the movie better. It’s better because I don’t have to read it. And it’s a good movie.

I thought the movie was a bit better because I think its more exciting and it describes the senerey a bit better than the book does. It also acts more realistic than the book and it has more adventurs than the book(I think).Their is also a lot more action than the book has, thats why I chose the movie. :)(:

I like the book because it gives you more time to predict .And because it is like a movie in your head .And it has a lot of action .

I like the novel because i can imagien the seen.I can also make there voises sound diffrent.And you can picture in your head that the war part’s are more drumatic.And diffrent stuff happens in the book than the movie.thats why I like the novel better.

I prefer the novel because it has more drama. The book has more fun things in it. Iliked the part when they had the war

I would perfer the movie for these reasons. 1: The movie seems shorter. 2: The movie you can see it. 3: The book takes a long time to read.

Alec

Leave a response - Create a free edublog to get your own comment avatar (and more!)

Your response:

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture.
Anti-Spam Image

Categories